Home Specials BCSP Se Three(3) identical situation-film songs of (3) different MDs for analytical study

Newsflash

We have launched a special section featuring transcripts and more from radio programs for the enjoyment of fans. Thanks a lot to Sujoy Chatterjee, Ramaswamy and other contributors to the section. If you wish to provide more such content or help in posting transcripts please contact the administrator. 

This new section canbe accessed by clicking on Radio Se in the Specials Menu. Enjoy!

You can also reach it by clicking  Radio Se
Three(3) identical situation-film songs of (3) different MDs for analytical study PDF Print E-mail
Written by bcsp   
Today's feature is on the above topic for individual study-n-reaction based 'solely on MERIT of
(a) the overall depth in the music composition, &
(b) the individual rendition-pairs and their performances. 

The (3) MDs , Singing Pairs-n-Films are : 
==========================

Anil Biswas  for Lata / Ira Nagrath from ANOKHA PYAR ('48);

 

ftp://anmolfankaar.unlimitedtree.com/public_html/sounds/bcsp/23_1_anokhapyar19_lata-iranagrath_anilbiswas.mp3
ftp://anmolfankaar.unlimitedtree.com/public_html/sounds/bcsp/23_2_doosrishaadi1947_rajkumari-zohra_ptgobindram.mp3
ftp://anmolfankaar.unlimitedtree.com/public_html/sounds/bcsp/23_3_devaki1951_jikki-pleela_g-ramanathan.mp3
 
Pt. Gobindram for Rajkumari / Zohrabai from DUSRI SHADI ('47)
 

 

&

G. Ramanathan for Jikki / P. Leela from the Tamil film : DEVAKI ('51)

 

 

All the above THREE/3 of them were MIGHTY Music Directors contemporary-wise in their creativeness-n-styles and had their 'share of LUCK' during their individual careers from 1940 -1960 or so.

Share Link: Share Link: Bookmark Google Yahoo MyWeb Del.icio.us Digg Facebook Myspace Reddit Ma.gnolia Technorati Stumble Upon
 

Comments  

 
0 # 2011-03-01 11:18
Both by music and singers I like the Doosri Shadi song. I totally disagrre with you when you call Rajkumari a thin voice. Her voice was a bit soft but equally weighty like most other singers of her time. Here, as much as Zohrabai. They were best friends and it is certainly a pleasure to hear them sing together. Thanks a lot for the rare gem.
 

Sorry, unregistered users are not permitted to post comments. Only registered users are permitted to post comments to restrict spam. Please login and post your comments. In case, you haven't registered please register. Procedure for it is available in the FAQ section. You may also use gmail credentials for logging in.

Admin's Note

Kyunki Har Ek Artist Zaroori Hota Hai!

This website is a project dedicated to artists of the Indian Subcontinent. It is under construction and can progress only with contributions by Everyone. There is lots to be done. Any one interested in contributing content and helping with making articles on the site (basic editing/blogging skills required) may please use the contact facility (or message on Anmol Fankaar group on Facebook) to get in touch with us for helping in the same. Contributions are needed for content of all Indian subcontinent films, artists, folk, regional and non-film work (music, arts and so on). Anyone ready to spare time may please contact (This is also a social work and hope to see more people doing it). We aim to be an archiving project as tribute to work of our artists. Request all to utilise this platform for furthering the task as a thanks to our earlier generations. Only registered users can post comments. You may use your gmail credentials to login also.

Main Menu

Translate

Chat